
Share a Memory:
Upon submitting your memory, please refresh your page to view your condolences.
Condolences:
Arthur H. Reeve
2026-10-19
Art Reeve passed away peacefully at the age of ninety-nine surrounded by family.
Arthur was born and raised by his parents Irving and Vecina Reeve in Englewood, New Jersey. He attended Dwight Morrow High School where John Travolta’s mother was his English teacher. He ran track and excelled at his studies. His yearbook caption read “the bright guy with the bright tie”. After a short time in the US Army at the end of WWII he attended Princeton and went on to complete his law degree at Columbia. In the summer of 1949, he met Barbara Nilson and they spent the next 70 years together raising a brood of four children: Susan, Virginia, Andrew and James.
Arthur practiced law for over fifty years in Englewood, NJ, first in partnership with his father, Irving Reeve and then later with partner Bruce LaSalla. As it turned out the biggest case of his life was to prosecute the murderer of his daughter, Susan, who was killed in 1975. In the hands of another very competent attorney, the complex case resulted in a favorable ruling and the defendant lost control of a multi-million-dollar inheritance. Arthur continued until his death to appear before the parole board every three years to keep the defendant behind bars, where he remains today.
Over the years Art broadened his network serving in many leadership roles in his community including President of the Englewood Men’s Club, President of Englewood Hospital, Town Magistrate in both Demarest and Closter NJ as well as President of the Bergen County Bar Association and as a Trustee of Valley Savings and Loan. Art never played golf or tennis, but he loved his garden. Every home he lived in he planted the most beautiful garden with his own sweat and fortitude. There was a time when he made a fire of leaves at his cottage on Shelter Island and nearly burned the neighbor’s house down. He gave a gift to the fire department that year. His son, Andy, would become the fire chief and commissioner of the Shelter Island Fire department some forty years later.
Arthur and Barbara raised their children in Demarest, NJ and spent summers on Shelter Island, NY but went on to live their retirement in Amelia Island, Florida. Art will forever be remembered as jokester and prankster. Those closest to him either loved or hated his humor but either way it was impossible to escape. His family will remember him as a father who spent wonderful quality time with his children, taking the family and grandma on memorable trips including discovering the USA in their Chevrolet in 1965, and to Puerto Rico on $6 a night. Those were the good old days.
Arthur is survived by his daughter, Virginia of Durham, NC and son, James of St Augustine, FL as well as four grandchildren and six great grandchildren. He is preceded in death by his daughter, Susan; son, Andrew; wife, Barbara; and sister, Jean.
Memories